Small business · Websites

We checked 27 small business websites from a phone. Here's what was quietly costing them calls.

Most of what goes wrong on a small business website is not the design. It is a phone link that dials the wrong number, a button that goes nowhere, or a tracking tag that stopped working years ago. None of it shows up unless you check.

WritingBy Landon LittleNovember 19, 20267 min read

How we checked

We read each site's raw HTML, the code your browser receives, and opened pages in a real browser where the HTML alone could not tell us what a visitor sees. We looked at the things that decide whether someone can reach the business: the phone number and its link, the buttons on the homepage, the contact page, and the tracking tags. We did not look at design, writing or search rankings.

The 27 sites were law firms, HVAC companies, roofers, insurance agents and one cleaning company. We are not naming any of them. The point is the patterns, and every one of these problems can show up on any small business site.

What we found, November 19, 2026
ResultSites
In good shape13 of 27
At least one problem that could cost a call or a lead13 of 27
Only an outdated copyright year1 of 27
A phone number problem of some kind7 of 27

The phone number: 7 of 27 sites had a problem

On a phone, the number should be a link. Tap it and the dialer opens with the number filled in. That link is a few characters of code, and it broke in four different ways:

  • 4 sites showed the number as plain text, with no tap-to-call link. On a phone, the visitor has to remember the number or copy it by hand.
  • 1 site showed no phone number at all on key landing pages, only a WhatsApp link and a form.
  • 1 site had a call button that showed the correct local number, but the link behind it dialed a different, out-of-state number. Most likely a leftover from the website template. Anyone who tapped it reached someone else.
  • 1 site had 3 of its 4 phone links written with parentheses and spaces inside the link, which some phones do not handle cleanly.

The out-of-state number is the one worth sitting with. The page looked right. The number on screen was right. Only the link was wrong, so the owner would never see it by looking at the site. They would only notice fewer calls.

Tracking that stopped working in 2023

2 sites still ran only Universal Analytics, the old Google Analytics. You can spot it in the code as a tag starting with "UA-". Google stopped processing Universal Analytics data in 2023, and neither site had the newer Google Analytics 4 installed. So the tag is still on the page, but Google Analytics isn't counting any visits. If anyone on the team is making decisions from that account, they are looking at old numbers.

When the page promises something it cannot do

  • 1 contact page said the business was "available 24/7" but had no form, only a phone number. At 2 a.m., a visitor who does not want to call has no way to leave their details.
  • 1 cleaning company listed 3 plans with no prices on any of them, only a "Request a Quote" button.

Two smaller things

  • 1 site showed a Cloudflare "verify you are human" page before the site loaded. This may depend on the visitor, so not everyone sees it, but some real customers will hit a check before they see the business at all. If you use Cloudflare, check whether a security setting is challenging ordinary visitors.
  • 1 site's only issue was an outdated copyright year in the footer. It does not stop anyone calling, but a visitor can read it as a sign nobody is looking after the site.

The five-minute phone test

You do not need tools to find most of this. Do it on your own phone, not a computer, because that is where most of these problems hide.

  1. Open your website on your phone, the way a customer would: search for your business name and tap the result.
  2. Tap your phone number. Does the dialer open, and is it your number? Try it on the homepage, the contact page and any page your ads send people to.
  3. Tap every button and link on the homepage. Each one should open a real page, not an error.
  4. Open the contact page after hours. If it says you are available, can someone reach you right now without calling? Send yourself a test form and check that it arrives.
  5. If you use WhatsApp or text links, tap them too and check they open a chat with you.
  6. Look for anything out of date: last year's copyright, an old offer, a page from an ad you stopped running.

For the tracking check, ask whoever set up the site whether it runs Google Analytics 4. If they are not sure, that is your answer.

If you want a wider view, in October 2026 we checked 2,137 contractor websites on a phone, looking at call links, booking and chat across eight trades.

Sources

Questions this post answers

Why is my website not getting calls?
Check the phone link first. In our check of 27 small business websites on November 19, 2026, 7 had a phone number problem: the number was not tappable, was missing from key pages, dialed a different number than the one on screen, or had a link a phone may not read cleanly. Open your site on your phone and tap the number to find out.
Why is click to call not working on my website?
The link behind the number is usually missing or written wrong. It should read tel:+1XXXXXXXXXX: tel:, a plus sign, the country code and the digits, with no spaces, dashes or parentheses. The number people see can be formatted however you like. In one site we checked, the visible number was right but the link dialed a different, out-of-state number.
What should a small business website checklist include?
Tap your phone number on a phone and check it dials you. Tap every homepage button and check none leads to an error page. Check the contact page works after hours, including a form or text option if you say you are available 24/7. Check WhatsApp links open a chat. And check the site runs Google Analytics 4, not only the old UA- tag Google stopped processing in 2023.
How do I know if my website still uses Universal Analytics?
Look for a Google tag that starts with "UA-". If that is the only Google Analytics tag on the site, Google Analytics isn't counting any visits, because Google stopped processing Universal Analytics in 2023. GA4 tags start with "G-". 2 of the 27 sites we checked had only the old tag.

Want a second pair of eyes on yours?

Send us your website. We read your public Google and Facebook ads and open the pages they send people to on a phone, then email you a short list of what we'd fix. Free, with no card and no account access.

Book a 20-minute call

Pick a time that works. Twenty minutes on video, no pitch. You leave knowing whether this is worth doing.